Phoenix Criminal Lawyer

Sign Language - Sexuality

Communicate About Intimacy

One of the most important things that need to be communicated in sign language, especially for adults, is sexuality. Books are available with sex signs, and a few signs are available on the web and in regular sign language dictionaries.

Sexual Sign Language Books

One book that focuses solely on sex signs is Signs of Sexual Behavior: An Introduction to Some Sex-Related Vocabulary in American Sign Language (compare prices) Another book, that appears to be out of print and unavailable most places, is Signs for Sexuality.

Sexual Sign Language Online

Here are selected sexual signs and their sources from the Sign Language Word Reference Guide at About Deafness/HOH:breast ASLPro.com
condom Handspeak.com *
intercourse ASL Browser
penis ASL Browser
sex Handspeak.com*, ASL Browser
sexy Handspeak.com*
vagina ASL Browser

* = Paid site

Sexual Sign Language Videos

The Captioned Media Program has human sexuality sign language videos:

  • TECHNICAL SIGNS: HUMAN SEXUALITY (TAPE 22)
  • TECHNICAL SIGNS: HUMAN SEXUALITY (TAPE 28)

Deaf history 1900’s

 Max A. Goldstein, “A note otologist in the U.S., was a strong advocate of the importance of residual hearing. In 1897 at the St. Joseph’s School for the Deaf in St. Louis, MO, he set up a series of acoustic exercises giving each child fifteen minutes practice daily in sound stimulation.” “The results were most encouraging in better speech and better comprehension of speech.” In 1914, Goldstein established The Central Institute for the Deaf in St. Louis, MO. A private orally-taught school with close cooperation between teachers and scientists in otolaryngology, neurology, phonetics and acoustics.

1941-1945 World War II - Hundreds of Deaf people in United States were active “on the home front” during the war to build bombs, bullets, planes, and tanks in defense industries. Deaf people worked in all capacities. Some were professional chemists; some were young men and women with no specific skills who came in from the surrounding farms. At least 40 companies reported in various newspapers that they were highly satisfied with their Deaf workers.

1951 - World Federation of the Deaf is organized in Rome, Italy. The president of WFD is Yerker Anderson, a native of Sweden and Professor of Sociology at Gallaudet University.

1964 Robert Weitbrecht, A Deaf man introduced an invention to help the Deaf to speak on the phone. The invention was an electronic device called an acoustic coupler that enables typewritten communication over the telephone through the use of a teletypewriter (TTD). In 1982, there were over 150,000 TTY sets in the U.S. Not only are they in Deaf people’s homes, but in many public places, businesses, airline reservation desks, police, fire departments, hospitals and schools. Because of this invention, Deaf people can now one step closer towards equal enjoyment of the technological luxuries and necessities of modern culture.

1967 National Theater of the Deaf is established in Chester, Connecticut.

1971 First open captioned commercial television in Boston, Mass.

1975 Congress passes Public Law 94-142, the “Education of all Handicapped Children Act.” Mainstreaming is accepted as current educational philosophy.

1978 Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 is passed. The law requires that all businesses, colleges and organizations which have federal contracts or receive federal funds be open and accessible to physically disabled persons.

1979 The National Captioning Institute was established to coordinate and encourage captioning of commercial and public television broadcasting.

1980 First closed captioning of commercial television aired for Deaf and Hard of Hearing viewers in Boston, Mass. with the captioning of Masterpiece Theater.

1980 Phillis Frielich was born February 29, 1944 in Devils Lake, North Dakota. There were nine children in her family who were all Deaf including her parents. She attended School for the Deaf in her area, and later went to Gallaudet College. She loved acting and performed in several productions. After graduating from Gallaudet in 1967, she joined NTD where she met her husband, Robert Steinberg, the company’s technical director. Later, her husband worked as a professor at the University of Rhode Island in the theater department where Frielich met Mark Medoff, a playwriter. It was the first time Medoff met someone that was Deaf. He found out that there were no roles in the theater for Deaf actors. He decided to write a play for Frielich. He named it Children of Lesser God. Frielich portrayed Sarah who was a young deaf charwoman who works at her old school and her husband as James, a speech teacher. After the play was presented at an NMSU workshop it was brought to Los Angeles and underwent some changes. It was a smash. In 1980 after being on Broadway, it won Best Play, Best Actress (Frielich), and Best Actor (Rubeinstein). In 1981, Frielich received the Theodore Roosevelt Rider Award from the Governor of North Dakota. In 1984, she played in Hands of its Enemy. In 1985, she was in a TV movie called Love is Never Silent. In 1991, she became the first Deaf person to be elected to the Screen Actors Guild Board in Hollywood.

1983 Boyce Williams retires after 38 years with the US Department of Vocational Rehabilitation. He was the first Deaf person to become Chief of the Deafness Branch of VR Services for the Deaf.

1984 Cochlear implant first approved for clinical use for persons 18 and older.

1986 Marlee Matlin wins academy award for the movie “Children of a Lesser God”, later stars on the television program “Reasonable Doubts” as a Deaf lawyer.

1988 Students and faculty at Gallaudet University protest the selection of Dr. Elizabeth Zinser a hearing president. Deaf President Now Protest (DPN) continues for one week, ending with the selection of I. King Jordan as the first Deaf President of Gallaudet University and a change in the members of the college Board of Directors.

1990 American with Disabilities Act passed, effective date - 1992 Provides non-discrimination in employment; accessibility to Interpreter services, assistive listening devices, TDD relay services, Caption TV, and telecommunication.

1993 Caption decoder chips required (under ADA) in all television sets 13″ and larger.

1993 Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) is passed. U.S. Department of Education establishes a Policy of Inclusion, giving all disabled students the right to attend neighborhood schools in a “least restrictive environment.” Residential Schools for the Deaf are labeled “most restrictive environment.” Policy of assimilation into society is the goal of IDEA. Residential schools for the Deaf in some states are forced to close because of decreasing enrollment, but number of Deaf teachers rise slightly (to 16%) as more teaching opportunities in the public schools and the desire for Deaf role models increase.

1994 Heather Whitestone was the first deaf person who won Miss America. Oral Deaf woman is admired for her personal achievement and her platform of encouraging Deaf and hearing people to set their goals high and work to achieve them. Speech vs. sign clouds her reign for a while, but she calms the storm by stressing individual differences and “it (speech) worked for me, but it does not work for all Deaf children.”

1995 Use of cochlear Implants increases. Nucleus 22 device and SPEAK Speech Processing system (developed at the University of Melbourne, Australia) are the latest technological advances in implantation.12,000 candidates have been implanted at a cost of approximately $40,000. Adults and Children severely to profoundly Deaf, age two and above are considered candidates. Many parents opt for cochlear implants and mainstreamed education as an educational plan for their Deaf children.

1998 The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) released new captioning rules for the broadcast and cable television industry. These new rules now require 100% of cable television to be captioned with eight years - 2006, and require real-time captioning for many local news programs. The FCC will also be revising its rule to require that at least 50% of a channel’s pre-rule programming have captions beginning on January 1, 2002.

  • 450 hours per calender quarter (25%), beginning Jan. 1, 2000
  • 900 hours per calender quarter (50%), beginning Jan. 1, 2002
  • 1350 hours per calender quarter (75%), beginning Jan. 1, 2004
  • 100% of new programming must be captioned, beginning Jan. 1, 2006

Deaf history 1800’s

Thomas Hopkins Gallaudet, 1787-1851, first went to England to “study the oral methods of the Braidwoods.” He applied for admission but because of complications he was denied. Sicard was in Paris lecturing at this time. Gallaudet went to Sicard and told him his mission. He was immediately invited to Paris to visit the school. He stayed their training, attending classes and receiving private lessons. He returned to America with Laurent Clerc and proceed to co-found the first America school for the Deaf with Laurent Clerc.

Laurent Clerc, 1785-1869, was a Deaf student who studied under De L’Eppe and Sicard. He graduated from and taught at the Royal Institution for the Deaf in Paris. He met an American, Thomas Hopkins Gallaudet. “Gallaudet had numerous opportunities to observe the brilliant work of Clerc, whom he called “a master teacher.” Clerc accepted Gallaudet’s offer to open the first School for the Deaf in the America. Clerc and Gallaudet arrived in the America and raised the needed funds to open a School for the Deaf. “In April 15, 1817, their mission was accomplished successfully and the first America School for the Deaf called First “Home” of Connecticut Asylum was established at Hartford, Connecticut. Clerc went on to become the most important influence on the education of the Deaf in the first half of the nineteenth century. His career as a teacher in America covered 41 years.”

Alice Cogswell, 1805-1830 - At the age of two years, she become ill with “spotted fever” (cerebra-spinal meningitis). This illness took her hearing and later she lost her speech as well. When the Hartford School for the Deaf was to be opened, Cogswell was first on the list. On the campus of the present American School for the Deaf at Hartford stands a beautiful statue of Gallaudet and Cogswell.

Horace Mann, 1796-1859, was a believer in state school. In 1837, he became secretary of the first Massachusetts school board. “Two years later, he brought about the opening of the first American Teacher’s Training College at Lexington, Ky.” He went to Europe to visit schools for the Deaf and was amazed to see how well Deaf children were lipreading and using speech in the German schools. Returning to America, he published a report of his findings. This interested parents who began to demand speech for their Deaf children.

Samuel Gridley Howe, 1801-1876 - Director of the Massachusetts for the Blind. He taught a Deaf-blind child by means of the manual alphabet. Howe accompanied Horace Mann to Europe to visit the Deaf schools. In 1864, “Howe and other interested men petitioned the Massachusetts General Court for an act to incorporate an oral school for the Deaf in the state.” “It was defeated through the influence of the school in Hartford.”

Amos Kendall, ?-1869 - “In 1856, Kendall wanted to found a small private school for the Deaf in Washington, D.C. made contact with the Gallaudets.” The new school was called Kendall School and Edward M. Gallaudet, the younger son of Thomas Hopkins Gallaudet was given charge of the new school. “After seven years, Congress refounded the school as Columbia Institution,” with Gallaudet as the president. “In 1894, the preparatory department was named Kendall school, to retain the name of the original founder.” The Institution was renamed Gallaudet College in honor of Thomas Hopkins Gallaudet. In 1864, this college became the first and only Institution of higher learning in the world exclusively for the Deaf.

Gardines Green Hubbard, father of a daughter who was deafened by scarlet fever at the age of four. His daughter was tutored by a hearing teacher who taught her orally. In March 1864, “Hubbard, Howe and other interested men petitioned the Massachusetts General Court for an act to incorporate an Oral School for the Deaf in the state.” “It was defeated through the influence of the school in Hartford.” Hubbard did not give up, instead he gave financial support to open a private school with Harriet Rogers as a teacher. Although there were only eight pupils, the school served as an advertisement to the public, for many visitors came to see the accomplishments through oral education. In 1866, Hubbard again tried to get the Massachusetts legislature to pass the bill, but again was defeated. About this time, the Governor received a letter from John Clarke, a philanthropist offering $50,000 towards the establishment of an Oral School for the Deaf. “The Governor sent a message to the legislature urging to have an oral school under state jurisdiction. On March 16,1867, Deaf youngsters were invited to Mrs. Quincy’s home for a demonstration. After the demonstration, the legislatures were pleased with it. They passed the bill. Harriet Rogers and her pupils moved to Northampton to organize the Clarke School for the Deaf in October, 1867.

Laura Redden Searing, 1840-1923, was born in February 9, 1840 in Somerset, Maryland. She became Deaf at the age of 10 when she contracted spinal meningitis attack, which also impaired her speech. This made her develop the habit of writing when she communicated with people. Her “pad & pencil” became her constant companions wherever she went. Laura worked hard having her speech understood but she never mastered lipreading and preferred her pad and pencil. After she graduated from Missouri School for the Deaf, Laura became an assistant editor in 1859. This talented woman began a long successful career as a journalist, biographer & poet. The highlight of her becoming an interviewer was when she interviewed President Lincoln, General Grant & General Garfield. During the Civil war, a young reporter was sent to Washington DC to cover the news for the St. Louis Republican newspaper. The writer of these war stories was “Howard Glyndon.” Some of the people who read the St. Louis Republican knew that “Howard Glyndon” was a woman & none of them knew that she was also Deaf! Her name was Laura Redden, the first Deaf woman to succeed in the field of journalism and literature. When the Civil War ended, she went to Europe where she learned French, German, Italian and Spanish. Laura also wrote for 2 New York newspapers, The Sun and The Times, in her spare time. Laura Redden Searing died on August 10, 1923. Her achievement as poet and journalist was recognized by her peers. She was included in the Dictionary of American Biography (1928) and her poems were featured in several anthologies of American literature.

Alexander Graham Bell, 1847-1922, was born in Scotland, second son of Alexander Melville Bell who taught diction and elocution (visible speech). Bell also could teach the same and was invited to Sarah Fuller’s School for the Deaf and later to the Clarke School. He was a convinced supporter of lipreading and speech in the education of Deaf children. In 1872, Bell opened a training school for the teachers of the Deaf in Boston. Having a lot of opposition from the big Deaf schools using silent methods, he soon gave it up. Bell started experimenting hoping to find some mechanical means of making speech visible and to develop amplification. During these experiments, Bell was led to the invention of the telephone. He received many prizes for his work and using this money, Bell founded the Volta Bureau in 1887. Bell believed “that Deaf children should be educated orally and in day school situations.”

Thomas Alva Edison, 1847-1931, was the Hard of Hearing Inventor of the phonograph, the incandescent lamp, the first electric light, the basic elements of movies, plus so much more. What many people are not aware of, is the fact that Edison had had hearing problems from childhood on. This hearing loss caused him some difficulty in school. In addition, he reportedly lost more of his hearing, becoming technically Deaf, in his early teens. The cause is not definitely known - it could have been a result of early childhood illness or the result of a “boxing” of his ears by a rail conductor, possibly a myth. While as an inventor Edison was involved with several things, ironically one of them was motion picture development. It is ironic that a person with hearing loss would have been so involved in the development of an entertainment mode that has largely been inaccessible to the Deaf and Hard of Hearing for so many years.

Milan Conference of 1880 - “On September 6, 1880, educators of the Deaf from all countries assembled at Milan for an International Congress.” The discussions were suppose to be about “School Buildings”, “Teaching”, and “Methods.” They passed over the first two questions and proceeded at once to the “methods.” Each person representing his country spoke about the method they used in the instruction and education of their children. Many used speech, others the “combined” system. The meeting closed by the President and several resolutions were put into adoption. The oral method was preferred. Children were to be admitted at the age of eight to ten years. A class should not have no more ten children in the Pure Oral Program. New children being reviewed should be in a class by themselves and not with children who were further advanced. The school term should be at least seven years or eight. Everyone attending the conference was inspired in hopes for a new progress in the education of the deaf. All countries except the United States adopted the oral method as the preferred method.

Deaf Schools, 1818-1912 - More than 30 schools for the Deaf were established by Deaf and hearing teachers from the American School for the Deaf and Gallaudet College.

1840-1912 Golden Age of Deaf Education

William E. Hoy, 1862-1961, was the first Deaf professional ball player in the major leagues starting in 1887. He is created with inventing the arm signals used by home plate umpires. “This signal became the tradition that has continued to this day.” He called “Dummy Hoy”. He was first in the hearts of his fellow Deaf Americans in the realm of sports and in 1951, the American Athletic Association of the Deaf established its own “Hall of Fame” honoring Deaf athletes by popular vote the first Deaf person to be enshrined in the “AAAD Hall of Fame” was William E. Hoy.

First Electric Hearing Aid - Some claim that Alexander Graham Bell’s telephone, developed in 1876, was conceived as an electric hearing aid for his mother. The first electric hearing aid may have been the Akoulathon, designed in 1898 by Miller Reese Hutchinson of the Akouphone Company in Alabama. The carbon transmitter was enlisted for uses such as the telephone and the electric hearing aid, which became commercially available in 1898. Hearing aids make sounds louder, either by mechanically funneling sound to the ear more directly or by electronic magnification. The first amplified hearing devices contained a battery-operated carbon transmitter and earphones. In 1898, the Akouphone Company marketed a carbon table model hearing aid that sold for $400. The carbon-type hearing aids gave amplification near the low end and the middle speech frequency range. The carbon transmitter was replaced by the vacuum tube in the 1920’s, and later produced the first transistor-based hearing aid. Smaller, more powerful and stable, all electric hearing aids used today are based on transistors.

Jacobo Rodriguez Pereira, Charles Michel De L’Eppe, Abbe Roch Sicard, Samuel Heinicke, Thomas Braidwood, J.F.L. Arnoldi

Jacobo Rodriguez Pereira, 1715-1780 - The greatest teacher of the Deaf in France. Pereira never had more than twelve pupils at one time. He offered two courses. “For the poorer and more numerous clients, he gave a short course of fifteen months which covered the current necessities for living.” The wealthy and more intelligent stayed four or five years. They were given a superior course. These pupils became successful and famous. He was very secret about his work that even his family did not know his methods. When he died, no one knew how to continue his work. His motto was “There will be no more Deaf mutes. There will be Deaf speaking ones.”

Charles Michel De L’Eppe, 1712-1789, was born in Versailles, France. He was a priest for 25 years then later became interested in teaching the Deaf. In 1760, he started a shelter for the Deaf in Paris and started teaching Deaf children in school conditions in Truffaut, France in 1762/63. There he lived with them, attending to their physical needs, supplying food, clothing and shelter as well as education.” In 1776, he published a book “Instruction of Deaf and Dumb using Methodical Sign.” He also wrote a dictionary primarily as “The Dictionary for the use of Deaf Mutes” and contained “more explanations than signs.” He was “famous in all of Europe for his work with Deaf mutes.”

Abbe Roch Sicard, 1742-1822, was chosen by the Archbishop of Bordeaux to be trained by De L’Eppe to be a teacher of the Deaf and then appointed him director of the school. Sicard opened the school for the Deaf in Bordeaux, France in 1782. In 1792, the September Massacres of the French Revolution broke out and Sicard was imprisoned and almost lost his life. He was in hiding for two years but during that time wrote a book “Theory of Signs,” an elaborate dictionary of signs.

Samuel Heinicke, 1727-1790 - Heinicke’s methods were strictly oral. He strongly opposed using sign language. He got interested in the Deaf after meeting a young Deaf mute boy. After reading Amman’s book “The Speaking Deaf”, he started to teach the boy. Heinicke was very successful; the boy learned to speak, lipread and write. He was so pleased and he decided to teach other Deaf pupils to understand oral speech as well as written communication. In 1778, he opened the first Oral School for the Deaf in Germany. He is known as the “Father of the German method.”

Thomas Braidwood, 1715-1806 - “The most outstanding name in England, concerned with the education of the Deaf, was that of a Scotsman, Thomas Braidwood.” He founded the first Britain school in 1760 as private academy for the Deaf in Edinburgh. The school moved to Hackney in London, England in 1783. In his school mean of communication until oral language could be established, he accepted natural gestures and signs, and recommended a two-hand alphabet which is still in use in England today. His grandson John Braidwood founded the first School for the Deaf in U.S.A. in 1812 in Cobb, Virginia but it was short-lived.

J.F.L. Arnoldi, a German pastor, he taught lipreading speech, reading and writing. He believed in a natural approach to language teaching. He felt that children of ages four and five could learn faster and easier the articulation of speech but the “development of ideas were more rapid in ten and eleven year olds. His main goal was to teach reading to his pupils. “He described and published his methods in a book in the year of 1777.”

Juan Pablo Bonet, John Bulwer, George Dalgarno, Johamn Konrad Amman

Juan Pablo Bonet, 1579-1620 - In 1620, he published his famous book “Simplification of Sounds and the Act of Teaching the Deaf to Speak.” He believed Deaf-mute should be forced to learn one hand manual alphabet using pictures illustrating the position of the hand for each letter before learning to speak and lipreading.

 John Bulwer, 1614-1684, was English physician published his first two books in 1644 “The Natural Language of the Hand” and another called “The Art of Manual Rhetoric.” He was convinced that the “language of the hand” was “the one language that was natural in all men especially for the deafened in the use of a manual alphabet.” In 1648, Bulwer published his famous book title “The Deaf and Dumb Man’s Friend.” This was the first English book explaining “the subject of deafness and its accompanying language problems, but had no bearing on the actual teaching of Deaf persons.”

 George Dalgarno, ?-1687 - In 1680, Dalgarno published a book titled “The Deaf and Dumb Man’s Tutor.” In this book, he had many theories of the different ways of teaching language to the Deaf. He knew that the Deaf could be taught to speak and lipread, but he felt that using the manual alphabet was more practical. He advised mothers to spell out on their fingers and at the same time point to the object she was naming.

 Johamn Konrad Amman, 1698-1774, was a doctor of medicine, but was interested in trying to educate Deaf mutes. He only worked on youths between eight and fifteen years of age. He wanted his pupils to have “a good clear voice and to control it well.” He learned that they “could feel the vibrations of his voice,” he placed “their hands on his throat as he taught.” He also had his pupils use mirrors in the speech practice. Lipreading was also part of the language achievement. He published two books, one in 1692 written in Latin and the other in 1700 called “A Dissertation Speech.”

Pedro Ponce De Leon,

1520-1584, Catholic monk, established the world’s first school for the Deaf at the Monastery of San Salvador near Madrid, Spain where he taught till his death. “He taught the Deaf mutes from birth to speak.” Peter of Ponce first taught them “to write while showing them with his finger the object which was named by the written characters; then drilling them to repeat with the vocal organs the words which correspond to these characters.” He was the inventor of this art and each pupil reasoned very well. He kept records of his methods and results but were destroyed in a fire. “In spite of his success and the favorable publicity of his work, at his death it seemed to die with him.”

Girolamo Cardano

1501-1576 was a Italian physician concerned about his Deaf child, Cardano came across Agricola’s book. He agreed that the “sense of hearing and the use of spoken words were not indispensable to understanding ideas.” Cardano also believed that the Deaf need to learn to read and write. “True, it is difficult but possible.” “We can, in reality, manifest our thoughts either with words or with gestures.” Cardano invented some kind of code for teaching but did not purse it instead went on studying other medicines.

Rudolphus Agricola

1443-1485, was interested in the Deaf and wrote a book “De Inventione Dialectica”. He wrote that a person who is born Deaf can express himself by putting down his thoughts in writing. The book was never published till a 100 years later.

History of the TTY

Still an Essential Communications Tool

They have largely been replaced by email, text pagers, and other modern forms of communication, but the basic TTY is still around.

Origins

A deaf scientist, Robert Weitbrecht, is credited with the development of the TTY in the 1960s. The earliest TTYs were huge hunks of metal with printer paper coming out of them. I remember seeing one in the home of a family friend in the early ’70s. and being quite impressed. These early TTYs are now antique, and can only be found in places such as the Smithsonian.

The cost was also a barrier that prevented the TTY from gaining widespread use and acceptance more quickly. I did not get one myself until the early 80s. Today, TTYs are available in a variety of models, from the most basic and inexpensive to highly sophisicated, computer-like models and compact, pocket-sized TTYs.

Books and publications

  • TDI, an organization that publishes an international “blue book” directory of TTY numbers, has published a cartoon history of the TTY, “One Thing Led to the Next, The Real History of TTYs.” This publication can be purchased by submitting an order form.
  • A Phone of Our Own: The Deaf Insurrection Against Ma Bell” - This book gives the full history of the development of the TTY, complete with the obstacles it had to overcome in order to come into existence.

Problems

The TTY has been plagued by problems:

  • Confusion over the proper terminology. Over the years, the TTY has also been known as a TDD. Was it a telephone typewriter for the deaf, a text telephone, or a telecommunications device for the deaf? Finally the TDI settled the issue by deciding that the proper term was TTY.
  • Its technology has been said to be old and incompatible with modern communications techology, such as computer modems.
  • Compatibility problems with competing TTY manufacturers. I can recall the frustrations of trying to hold conversations with friends whose TTYs were different from mine.
  • Lack of awareness of TTYs in the hearing world. Ask the average hearing person on the street “Do you know what a TTY is” and the answer is likely to be “huh?

Deaf History - Milan 1880

Event with Powerful Repurcussions

Milan 1880. No other event in the history of deaf education had a greater impact on the lives and education of deaf people. This single event almost destroyed sign language.

What Happened in 1880?

In 1880, there was an international conference of deaf educators, the Second International Congress on Education of the Deaf. At this conference, held September 6-11, 1880, a declaration was made that oral education was better than manual (sign) education. A resolution was passed banning sign language. The only countries opposed to the ban were the United States (represented by Edward Miner Gallaudet, Rev. Thomas Gallaudet, Issac Peet, James Denison, and Charles Stoddard) and Britain. The sign supporters tried, but failed, to get their voices heard. Here are the first of 8 resolutions passed by the convention:

1. The Convention, considering the incontestable superiority of articulation over signs in restoring the deaf-mute to society and giving him a fuller knowledge of language, declares that the oral method should be preferred to that of signs in the education and instruction of deaf-mutes.

2. The Convention, considering that the simultaneous use of articulation and signs has the disadvantage of injuring articulation and lip-reading and the precision of ideas, declares that the pure oral method should be preferred

The other resolutions dealt with instruction of impoverished deaf students, how to instruct deaf students orally, the need for instructional books for deaf oral teachers, the long-term benefits of oral instruction, the optimal ages for oral instruction and length of instruction, and phasing out of manually instructed students. A photocopy of the Milan resolutions is in the book Deaf Heritage.

How Could This Happen?

It was a foregone conclusion. The outcome was basically “fixed” because the conference was planned and organized by a committee that was against sign language. This committee selected the attending representatives — more than half were known oralists from France and Italy. Although other topics were supposed to be discussed, the conference focused on the methods of instruction, and representatives talked about the method of instruction used in their schools - either speech or combined speech and sign. Immediately after these presentations, the resolutions were made.

What Was the Immediate Effect?

The repurcussions to Milan were immediate:

  • Deaf teachers lost their jobs
  • The fledgling National Association of the Deaf attracted more supporters as deaf people fought to save their language and culture
  • The president of Gallaudet College (now University) decided to retain sign language on the Gallaudet campus. This monumental decision may have been largely responsible for sign language’s survival.

What Was the Long-Term Impact?

Milan 1880 is of such significance in deaf history that it has been commemorated in artworks, such as the artwork of artist Mary Thornley, who has done a painting showing hearing “hunters” seeking to shoot down ASL.

In October 1993, Gallaudet University held a conference, “Post Milan ASL and English literacy.” The conference proceedings included an esay, “Reflections upon Milan with an eye to the future,” by Katherine Jankowski.

In retrospect, one could say that in the years since, sign language and oralism have learned to co-exist peacefully. There will never be another Milan 1880.

This article was in response to a visitor’s information request. Do YOU have an information request? Send it in!

Next Page »